onsdag 8. oktober 2014

Supercapacitors for peak shifting over short durations in PV-systems

Xuemei Cheng, Wesley Dose, Thomas Hempel, Øyvind Storesund Hetland, Kine Solbakken and Björn Veit at NorRen Summer School 2014


In recent years there has been a growing emphasis on harnessing energy from renewable sources. Photovoltaic (PV) cells have demonstrated great potential as a cheap and reliable source of clean, renewable energy, and PV production facilities are now being deployed at a high pace globally. The output from a PV production system naturally varies with the cycles of the sun (e.g., day and night), requiring other sources of energy to be available when sunlight is scarce or absent. There is another, less well known, issue in PV systems however: the variability of PV output even while the sun shining, due to second- and minute- resolution disturbances in the light absorbed by the solar panel. These fluctuations are usually due to clouds, but any moving object that occludes the path of sunlight will contribute. As more and more small scale PV systems are connected to the local grid, these fluctuations may prove a problem through grid voltage instabilities and temporary grid overproduction due to sharp local peaks in production. A possible remedy to these issues could be to somehow store energy when the system experiences a short spike in production, and then release this energy again when a drop in production occurs. This process would result in a smoother output from the PV system, with no, or minimal, loss in overall production.

How could we implement such an ‘energy buffer’ in a real-life application? The most common alternatives are batteries and capacitors. A battery can offer a high energy capacity (Wh) but low power (acceptance/delivery time, W), while the capacitor offers very high power, but can only store a small amount of energy. Another device has recently joined the market however: the electrochemical capacitor (also known as supercapacitors or ultracapacitors). The supercapacitor fills the intermediate region between batteries and capacitors. It could be considered as a high-capacity capacitor, and it shows considerable promise in storing seconds worth of energy from PV output, even from larger PV systems, while also providing the high rate energy storage/release required.

The problem – Strong fluctuations in the solar radiation

Figure 1 shows the real measured solar radiation in Chemnitz, Germany in the year 2001. The time increment between the measured values is 1 second. Over this time period a total of 28,947,592 data pairs were collected. The odd area at the baseline between day 50 and day 110 is the result of lighting from a construction site overnight.

Figure 1: Measured solar radiation

Figure 2 shows the typical waveform of the solar radiation of a (summer-) day.

Measured solar radiation of one day

In addition to the expected daily variation in PV output, it can also be seen in Figures 1 and 2 that changes in weather conditions, especially clouds, leads to large fluctuations in the output on very short timescales.


A supercapacitor stores energy electrostatically on the surface of two conducting plates. Figure 3 shows a schematic construction of a cylindrical capacitor.

Figure 3: Schematic construction of a cylindrical capacitor

One of the characteristics of supercapacitors is the very large surface area of the conducting plates and the very thin separation layers between them. The result is a very high power density, which means that the storage device is able to absorb and release energy very quickly, within seconds. This feature will likely make the supercapacitor very suitable for solving the problem of fluctuating output from PV, compared to a battery which needs between 1-10 hours to charge. A limitation of the supercapacitor is the energy density. Compared to a battery, a supercapacitor can store only 10% of the energy a battery can store per unit volume.

Another issue related to supercapacitors is that the cost is currently very high. Actual prices on a cell level are in the range of 0.12 NOK/F to 0.16 NOK/F (0.015 €/F to 0.02 €/F). The price largely depends on the manufacturer and on the quantity of ordered cells. However, over the last few years the price has decreased quickly as production volumes for commercialized variants of the supercapacitor has increased.

Simulation results of PV-only and a PV- supercapacitor system

In order to better assess the usability of supercapacitors for PV output stabilization, some circuit simulations were conducted based on the measured PV output shown above.

In the simulation schematics (Figure 4 and 5) the PV-system was modelled with a self-developed power source as a 1 kWPeak solar system with a rated voltage of 100 V and a rated current of 10 A. For a better understanding of the "real problem" the load was simulated as an ohmic resistance. In real applications there is in most cases a DC to AC converter that is coupled to the public grid.

Figure 4: Circuit without supercapacitors, used for simulation.

The supercapacitor module in Figure 5 was modelled with the usual equivalent circuit diagram that consists of a capacitance C, a serial resistance RESR and a parallel resistance RP. The module was designed to include a series connection of 40 cells (Maxwell BCAP1200 [1]) with the features listed in Table 1.

Capacitance, C
1,200 F
Serial resistance, RESR
0.58 mΩ
Rated voltage
2.7 V
Maximum voltage
2.85 V
Maximum operating current
930 A
Short circuit current
4,700 A
260 g
Operating temperature
-40°C .. +65°C
Usable specific power
5,800 W/kg
Specific energy
4.7 Wh/kg
Stored energy
1.22 Wh
Table 1: Cell parameters of a Maxwell BCAP1200

Based on the physical fundamentals of capacitors the string/module parameters can be calculated to the values shown in Table 2.

Capacitance, C
30 F
Serial resistance, RESR
23.2 mΩ
Rated voltage
108 V
Maximum voltage
114 V
Maximum operating current
930 A
Stored energy
48.8 Wh
Table 2: Module parameters of a string of 40 Maxwell BCAP1200 in series connection

Figure 5: Circuit with supercapacitors, used for simulation. The simulation was based on 40 supercapacitors connected in series, each with a capacitance of 1,200F.

Figure 6a: Simulation results. Red line shows a smoother VM2-voltage than the gray-blue line, as a result of the added supercapacitors.

Figure 6b: Zoom of the simulation results shown in Figure 6. Red line shows a smoother VM2-voltage than the blue line, as a result of the added supercapacitor

Figures 6a and 6b shows the comparison between a supercapacitor coupled system and a PV-system without supercapacitors. In this case, the supercapacitor is shown to reduce the problematic voltage peaks from ~123 V to ~98 V (reduction of approx. -20%).

Generally, it can be said that the higher the fluctuations, the higher the benefit gained by using supercapacitors.


Through the simulations we have seen that supercapacitors are well suited for smoothing the highly fluctuating output from PV systems, both by smoothing the output and removing sharp voltage peaks. From the results presented above it is reasonable to believe that adding a larger number of supercapacitors will result in an even smoother power output. In situations where short bursts of overproduction leads to disconnection from the local grid, adding supercapacitors will likely increase the energy efficiency of the PV. Instead of disconnection, the peaks will be removed and delivered to the grid at a time when the production is lower. Also, in the case of systems in which PVs are connected directly to a battery, the battery is expected to benefit from a smoother PV output by way of more constant charging rates, which should increase the lifetime of the storage device. However, adding supercapacitors to the PV system adds a significant cost due to the current price for supercapacitors. At the moment, it is less likely that there will be any economic benefits from adding the supercapacitors to the system unless the cost is significantly reduced.


[1] Maxwell Technologies, Datasheet K2 Ultracapacitors - 2.7V Series, BCAP1200,


[2] http://www.adapted-solutions.com/web/AdaptedSolutionsEnglish/


18 kommentarer:

  1. Simple trick to cut your power bill by 75%:

    Want to know how to easily produce all of the green energy you could ever want right at home?

    And you will be able to make your home totally immune from power outages, blackouts, and energy grid failures
    so even if everyone else in your area (or even the whole country) loses power…you won’t.


  2. Thanks for this post, I really appriciate. I have read posts, all are in working condition. and I really like your writing style. Keep it up like. solar security light with motion sensor

  3. Dear Admin,
    Greetings of the day. Thanks for sharing a worthwhile post which represents your creativeness. See: Variance TV Removal Guide and Tips TO AVOID BEING HACKED

  4. This one was a great piece of information! It was simple and easy to understand. Thanks and keep up the good work!Instagram Phishing Scam

  5. Thankful to you for this amazing information sharing with us. Get website designing and development services by Ogen Infosystem.
    Top 5 Website Development Company in Delhi

  6. Your content is really awesome and understandable, thanks for the efforts in this blog. Visit Mutual Fund Wala for Mutual Fund Schemes.
    Investment Advisor in Delhi

  7. Decent, Get Service for Night out page 3 parties and this magnificent service provided by Lifestyle Magazine.
    Lifestyle Magazine India

  8. Great, I think this is one of the best blog in past some time I have seen. Visit Kalakutir for Fleet Painting, Godown Line Marking Painting and Caution & Indication Signages.
    Caution & Indication Signages

  9. Online Front is the best website development company in India. Who provides professional website development services. We have a team of expert website designing and development. who definitely build a customize and attractive website for you and your targeted customer. you can generate unlimited revenue by promoting your online store with digital marketing services. and, the online front is a one-stop digital solution where you can get full services related to your online business.
    Visit :-
    Website Development Company In Delhi
    Digital Marketing Company In Delhi
    Website Development Packages
    Website Designing company in delhi
    Social Media Management Packages
    Email Marketing Services

    Visit Our Partner’s Site:-

    Gas Stove Repair & Services in Delhi
    B2B Marketplace in Delhi
    Satta King

  10. Since 2010, Lakshay Arora Stock Broker in Delhi 9+ year's Experience , We are deal in Intraday tips provider in Delhi, Stock Market Expert in Delhi, Mutual funds Expert in Delhi, Types of Investment and Demate Account Service in Delhi etc. Contact us for these types of services

  11. great and nice blog thanks sharing..I just want to say that all the information you have given here is awesome...Thank you very much for this one.
    solar energy advantages in points

  12. Since Metsolar is working side by side with research institute of photovoltaics – we constantly innovate to deliver latest photovoltaics technologies to our production and to adapt to changing needs of solar market. Our design and development team will assist through all stages of project development: from design sketch to working prototype and series production.
    PV storage forecast